Zimbabwe Democracy On Trial: A Chronology Of A Stolen Election
May 10th, 200829 March 2008
7 pm.
Polls close throughout the country with few reported incidents.
Reconciliation of ballot papers and counting process takes place with few reported incidents.
10 pm.
Results begin to be sent to MDC Command Center by MDC polling agents.
Throughout the night, after counting is completed, V11 tally forms are posted outside all (+/- 9200) polling station as required by law. MDC heard of few incidents. Some rural counting was stopped until morning because of lack of electricity. This is a consensual agreement of all parties in these polling stations.
29-30-31 March
Counting is completed at all polling stations. The Representatives of all Parties agree and sign off on the results for each Polling Station on a form called a V11, copies of which are posted outside the Polling Station for public viewing as required by law.
(MDC polling agents report the results by SMS and phone to MDC election command center after the count is completed. 85% of polling agents report V11 results by 31 March.)
The V11 forms are then transported by ZEC to the ward level Command Centres where they are summarized into V23 forms. The Results of these Council Elections are announced and a copy posted outside. Ballot boxes remain at the Polling Stations and are only moved to the Constituency Command Centres at a later stage.
These V23 forms then travel with Police/ZEC vehicles to the 210 Constituency Command Centres for tallying of House of Assembly seats. This process is largely completed by ZEC officials by 31 March. Results for each of the 207 House of Assembly seats are announced by Constituency Election Officers and again the results are posted outside for public viewing.
MDC hears of no cases where Constituency Election Officers deviated from this procedure.
These V23 forms travel to the Senatorial Command Centers for compilation of Senate results. Senate election results are tallied and winners announced. This is mostly completed by 31 March.
The V23 forms then traveled to Provincial Command Centres where all the results for each Province are tallied to get Provincial Results. No results are announced at this stage of the process. The V23 forms for each Province are then moved for submission to the National Counting Center in Harare.
1 April
Chief Election Agents (or candidates) for President assemble at the Sheraton Command Center to begin the final verification process which started at 2.30 p.m.
By 3.30 p.m. verification is completed of Presidential results of both Harare and Bulawayo provinces with minor amendments. Chief Election Officers of the MDC and the Independent parties, (ZANU PF was not present), sign off on the figures for these provinces.
Verification process begins for Mashonaland Central. MDC’s chief electoral agent notices some high figures in some constituencies and requests to verify the V11 forms tally with ZEC numbers.
MDC Chief Election Agent is told by ZEC that the V11s are still in the province.
ZEC says, “Once the V11s are assembled we will continue with the process.” ZEC notes to the chief election agents, “there will be some logistical problems” in getting the V11s.
MDC offers to loan ZEC some fuel to assist with these problems in retrieving the V11s from provincial centers. This offer is not accepted.
1-8 April
MDC hears nothing from ZEC at all.
8 April
MDC learns that ZEC Counting Center at the Sheraton has been dismantled.
Chief Election Agent meets ZEC official, where he is having breakfast, who reports that it had to be closed because of ZEC’s financial constraints but that “the verification team is ‘somewhere.’
MDC was not informed that the Counting Command Center was now closed.
MDC eventually hears “from the grapevine” that the verification center has moved to Room 1611 of the Sheraton.
MDC is told, however, that armed people surround the room and that they “wouldn’t be allowed anywhere near”. (MDC never confirmed that police were armed.)
9 April
MDC verification team decides to move out of Sheraton Hotel because of budget constraints.
9-29 April
MDC hears nothing from ZEC except for Pamire who called approximately twice in the week on behalf of Chief Election Officer Sekeramayi to say “they are still working on the V11’s”.
29 April
Chief Election Agents and/or candidates are invited to verification exercise at 2:30 pm on 1 May at the Sheraton Conference Center.
MDC expresses reservations about delay in calling them to the verification center.
Both MDC and Simba Makoni demand to know what they had done with their votes for all these weeks. This was well articulated by Makoni.
MDC Chief Election Agent states, “We need to agree on the methodology of the whole exercise. We should all understand what verification is so we are all clear right from the beginning.”
He states: “All must agree that the counting center is like a polling station and processes that take place in a polling station have to apply to the verification exercise.”
After agreement on methodology, MDC request the national vote total according to ZEC.
ZEC complies.
MDC then asks for the national total broken into each province and then each constituency.
ZEC complies.
But then ZEC asks MDC and the other candidates to provide ZEC with their own vote totals.
MDC rejects this request, telling ZEC that ZEC is the official authority running the election.
MDC notes that its figures are not necessary to provide because it is ZEC’s numbers that must stand in the court of law, not MDCs which were gathered from V11 forms posted on polling stations.
Makoni and ZANU PF provide all their count figures to ZEC.
MDC gives only its own National Total and Morgan Tsvangirai’s Total. ZEC then punches these figures into their computer and they themselves come up with the percentage figure of 50.3%.
ZEC asks MDC for its Provincial and other candidate’s breakdowns. MDC says it is not its business to provide ZEC numbers for its competitors. Chief Election Agents says “I have come to tell you, I am telling you now, MDC won this election.”
MDC sees no need for ZEC to produce every V11 tally sheet for the entire country. It requests ZEC to provide V11s only in places where it believes that turnout spikes indicate MDC may have been cheated.
ZEC continued to tell MDC, “Give us your numbers.”
Finally ZEC says, “We don’t seem to be making any progress.”
ZEC then asks MDC to bring its figures “tomorrow or they will be excluded from the process.”
MDC tells ZEC that its secretariat had not included the number breakdowns in their briefing packs that day and would return with them. Verification then adjourns and arguments postponed until the following morning.
2 May
ZEC again calls upon MDC to present its detailed figures as ZANU and Makoni had done. The fourth candidate had no figures at all so MDC said, “We will help you.”
MDC agrees to provide ZEC the provincial breakdowns.
ZEC then says, “We have a big problem with figures, what’s the way forward?”
MDC requests the V11s to verify the numbers provided by ZEC, especially in Mashonaland West Province.
MDC agents says, “We need to agree on the number of wards and polling stations in that province” in order to ensure it receives the full compilation of V11 forms.
The process of verification then starts soon after 10.00 am.
First V11 form: No problems.
Second V11 form: No problems.
Third V11 form: Problems. Form has no MDC signature. ZEC explains this could be for two reasons, either the polling agent wasn’t there or he refused to sign. MDC says, “Okay. We will investigate but give them the benefit of the doubt.” MDC notes down this anomaly.
Fourth V11 form: No problems.
Fifth V11 Form: Problems. “Form” is actually handwritten piece of paper, not an official form, but the MDC polling agent had signed it. MDC tells ZEC it needs to identify and query the polling agent for this polling station.
Sixth V11 form: No problems.
Seven V11 form: No problems.
After reviewing only seven V11’s, the verification process is then abruptly stopped at 11.20 by the Chief Election Officer Sekeremayi who states, “We can no longer continue this process. If we continue this process it will take four weeks.”
MDC election agent responds, “You have had our votes for four weeks; we are prepared to wait four more weeks. We want a credible and transparent verification process.”
The meeting is adjourned until 2:00 pm.
When Chief Election Agents return it is a markedly hostile environment. Chief Election Officer Sekeremayi simply reads a statement saying he will announce result. He states, “If parties are dissatisfied with the results, they can go to court.” He then proceeds to formally announce the result, despite voluminous protestations, (including protests from Makoni himself).
MDC responds to the announcement telling Sekeramayi it will reject the result because the legally-mandated verification process has not taken place. Accordingly, MDC does not sign the results verification form as required by law, and as mandated at the SADC Extraordinary Summit in Lusaka. SADC rep Kingsley Mamabolo and Salamao are also present when the verification was precipitously stopped. (The SADC Reps indicate that they are only here to observe and therefore cannot do or say anything.)
(Source: via email)
(Sponsor Link: OfferForge | kalahari.net | bidorbuy )
Posted by mandebvhu